Free · built by hand

Get your Online Visibility Review

Your Google scorecard, quick wins and a 90-day roadmap for your business. In your inbox within 1 business day.

No spam. We never share your info.

All articles
Article

What's the Most Reliable Source of Information Now? Google, AI, TikTok, Reddit and More, Checked

Brent Nickles11 min read
Illustration on a dark blue background: a semicircle gauge running from red to green with its needle pointing toward green, surrounded by six white rounded cards showing simple icons for search, video, chat bubbles, an AI sparkle, a star rating and a newspaper, each with a short colored bar underneath.

Short answer: There isn't one app you can trust for everything. The most reliable source of information is the original source (the study, the official record, the company itself), checked against one more independent source. Google is a good map to those sources. AI is a fast summary that gets things wrong more often than people think. TikTok, Instagram, X, Reddit and LinkedIn are great for tips and real-life opinions, and weak as proof.

Here's what I keep noticing. People tell me all the time they found us by asking ChatGPT. Other people tell me they "saw it on TikTok" like that settles it. And almost everybody I talk to says the same thing: I don't know who to believe anymore.

So I went and looked at the best research I could find. Not hot takes. The big surveys from Oxford's Reuters Institute and Pew Research, a large test of AI answers by public broadcasters, and the latest survey on how people pick local businesses. Here's what they say about where people get information, how far each source can be trusted, and what that means for you, both as a person reading the internet and as a business owner who wants to be found on it.

Where people get their information now

The big shift happened this year. Worldwide, social media and video apps are now the most common way people get news, ahead of both TV and news websites. 30% of people now say social and video are their main source, up from 22% five years ago.1

In the US, the top social sources for news are Facebook and YouTube, then Instagram and TikTok. X, Reddit and LinkedIn are much smaller.2 But age changes everything. Among Americans 18 to 29, 43% regularly get news on Instagram, 39% on TikTok and 18% on Reddit. Among people 65 and older, it's 8%, 4% and 1%.2

Search is still huge. 70% of American adults get news from search engines often or sometimes.3 And AI is the newcomer: 15% of Americans now get news from AI chatbots at least sometimes, up from 9% a year earlier.3

Here's the part that surprised me. People know a lot of this isn't trustworthy, and they use it anyway. The Reuters Institute put it nicely: people are choosing convenience over confidence. Trust in news on social media is 22% worldwide, and trust in AI chatbot answers is 20%, yet usage keeps growing.1 On Facebook, Instagram and TikTok, most people say they only see news while they're there for something else.1

So people aren't really choosing their information sources. A lot of it just shows up while they're scrolling.

Your information diet, explained like food

Think about information the way you think about food. You can eat out of the vending machine every day. It's fast and it's right there. But you probably wouldn't plan your health around it.

SourceIt's like...Good forWatch out for
The original source (the study, the law, the company's own website)A home-cooked meal where you bought the groceriesThe actual factsIt takes a little more time
Established news outletsA good restaurant with a health inspectionChecked reporting with names attachedEvery outlet has its own angle
Google searchThe grocery storeFinding the original sourcesAds and junk sit on the same shelves
AI chatbots (ChatGPT, Gemini)A smoothieQuick, easy explanationsYou can't see everything that went in
YouTubeA cooking showDeep dives and how-tosAnyone can host a show
TikTok and InstagramCandy at the checkoutSpotting what's trendingShort, emotional, rarely sourced
RedditA neighborhood potluckReal people's real experiencesSome dishes are great, some will make you sick
XHot sauceBreaking news, fastBurns hot, often one-sided
LinkedInA business lunchIndustry chatterEveryone is selling something
Online reviewsAsking the people at the next tableWhat it's like to be a customerFake reviews exist

Nothing on that list is "bad." A potluck can be the best meal of your year. You just don't eat everything on the table without asking who made it.

The reliability report card, source by source

You might want a percentage for each platform. "TikTok is 60% reliable." I looked. That number doesn't exist, and anyone who gives you one made it up. Accuracy depends on the topic and on who posted it. What does exist are trust surveys (how much people believe each source) and spot-checks (researchers testing actual answers). Here's what those show.

Google search. Trust in answers to news searches is significantly higher than trust in news on social media or from AI chatbots.1 That makes sense. Search doesn't write the answer. It points you to sources, and you pick. The catch: Google now often answers with an AI summary at the top, and people click through to real sources far less when that summary shows up.4 Scroll past it and look at who's actually behind the information.

AI chatbots (ChatGPT, Gemini, Copilot, Perplexity). In a big test by 22 public broadcasters in 18 countries, 45% of AI answers about the news had at least one significant problem, and 31% had serious sourcing problems, like missing, misleading or wrong attributions.5 One example from the study: ChatGPT reported Pope Francis as the current pope months after he had died.5 AI is amazing for explaining things. It's risky as the last word on facts, especially anything recent. Ask it for its sources, then open them.

TikTok and Instagram. 20% of Americans regularly get news on TikTok, up from 3% in 2020.2 In a 2022 test of TikTok search results on big news topics, 105 of the 540 videos reviewed (19.4%) contained false or misleading claims.6 That's one older study, so treat it as a warning sign, not a current score. The format is the real issue: TikTok news videos skew under two minutes,1 and a short, emotional clip rarely shows where the claim came from.

YouTube. The biggest video network for news around the world.1 It holds everything from real newsrooms and doctors to someone guessing in their car. The channel matters more than the platform.

Facebook. Still the biggest platform for news in the US (40% regularly get news there)2 and worldwide.1 What you see depends heavily on who you follow and what the feed decides to show you.

X. Fast for breaking news, and still very influential in politics and media.1 Only 10% of US adults regularly get news there now.2 Speed and accuracy often don't travel together.

Reddit. Only 9% of US adults regularly get news there, but 18% of adults under 30 do.2 Reddit shines for "what was it really like?" questions. Just remember that upvotes measure popularity, not accuracy, and most posters are anonymous.

LinkedIn. About 6% of US adults regularly get news there.2 It's useful for what's happening in your industry. Keep in mind most posts are also somebody's marketing. (Yes, including mine.)

Creators and influencers. 21% of Americans regularly get news from news influencers, including 38% of adults under 30.3 Worldwide, people find creators more entertaining and relatable, and less trustworthy and impartial, than traditional news.1

News organizations. Trust in news is low and falling worldwide, at 37%, and 25% in the US.1 Pew asks a softer question ("do you have at least some trust?") and gets bigger numbers: 75% of Americans trust local news at least somewhat, 62% national news and 38% social media sites.7 Pew's numbers actually went up this year. Different questions, same pattern: established outlets still beat social media on trust.

So what is the most reliable source of information?

Here's my honest answer. The most reliable source of information is the one closest to the facts, backed up by a second source that didn't copy the first.

Think of it as a ladder:

  1. Top rung: the original source. The actual study, the government record, the manufacturer's spec sheet, the business's own website.
  2. Established outlets and real experts with their names on it and something to lose if they're wrong.
  3. Search engines, used as a map to rungs 1 and 2.
  4. AI chatbots, as a fast summary you then check.
  5. Social media, as a tip that something is worth looking into. Not as proof.

And before you believe or share anything important, ask three questions:

  • Who said it? A real name, a real organization, or "a guy on TikTok"?
  • How do they know? Were they there, did they test it, or are they repeating someone?
  • Who else says so? Can you find it from one more source that isn't just quoting the first one?

If you can't answer all three, it's not a fact yet. It's a rumor with good lighting.

How people really make decisions (and why it matters for your business)

Now flip it around. If you own a business, your customers are going through this exact same mess, just with you as the topic.

The latest local consumer survey shows people don't rely on any single place anymore. They check several. 97% read reviews, and the average person uses six different review sites before choosing a business.8 Google is still number one, but its share dropped from 83% to 71% in a year, while ChatGPT and other AI tools jumped from 6% to 45%.8

And they double-check. After reading positive reviews, 54% go to the business's website.8 About half (49%) trust online reviews as much as a recommendation from someone they know.8

So here's the picture. Someone hears about you on Facebook, asks ChatGPT about you, reads your Google reviews, checks Reddit, and then lands on your website to decide. Every one of those places is a "source" about your business. If they disagree, people get nervous and pick someone else.

That leads to the most important idea in this whole post for business owners:

Be the original source about your own business. Your website is the home-cooked meal. It's the one place you fully control. When it clearly answers what customers ask (what you do, where, for whom, what it costs, what people say about you), AI tools and search engines have something solid to pull from, and customers have something solid to land on.

If you want a deeper look at how ChatGPT decides who to recommend, start with how to earn AI citations and what the new ChatGPT business profile means.

Here's what I would do

For your own information diet, this week:

  1. Pick two "top rung" sources for the stuff that matters to you (your health, your money, your industry) and go to them first.
  2. When AI gives you a fact you'll act on, ask for the source and open it. If it can't give one, don't use it.
  3. Treat social posts as tips. Interesting? Go find it in one more place before you believe or share it.
  4. Use the three questions: who said it, how do they know, who else says so.

For your business, this week:

  1. Ask ChatGPT and Google about yourself, the way a customer would: "Who's the best [what you do] in [your town]?" Write down what they say and who shows up.
  2. Make your facts match everywhere. Same name, phone, address, hours and services on your website, Google Business Profile, Facebook and review sites.
  3. Answer your top five customer questions on your website, in plain English. That's what both people and AI are looking for.
  4. Ask for reviews every week. Fresh, real reviews are the "who else says so" for your business.
  5. Add "ChatGPT / AI" to your "how did you hear about us?" question. Most analytics can't see those leads yet, so you have to ask.
  6. Put a number on it. Our free SEO ROI calculator shows what showing up on Google and in AI search could be worth to you.

Radical transparency: what we do

You knew it was coming.

We're a marketing company. We build High-Performance Websites and run SEO and AI search plans that help businesses show up on Google, in the map pack and in tools like ChatGPT. Most of that work is exactly what this post describes: making your website the clear, original source about your business, and making sure the rest of the internet agrees with it.

Now the honest part. Nobody can control what ChatGPT, TikTok or Reddit says about you, and anyone who promises a guaranteed AI mention is selling you something they can't deliver. What we can do is give those tools better, clearer, more consistent information to work with. And since this whole post is about checking sources, check ours: every number above links to where it came from.

The bottom line

There's no single trustworthy app. There's a trustworthy habit: go to the original source, then confirm it somewhere else. Use Google as your map, AI as your shortcut and social media as your tip line.

And if you run a business, remember your customers are doing the same thing with you. Make it easy for them. Be the original source.

Your homework: ask ChatGPT "who's the best [what you do] near [your town]?" tonight. If you don't like the answer, grab a free Online Visibility Review from the button at the top of this page.

Be kind to your future business. What's your online game plan?

Footnotes

  1. Reuters Institute for the Study of Journalism, "Overview and key findings of the 2026 Digital News Report", June 16, 2026. Online survey of almost 100,000 people in 48 markets. ↩ ↩2 ↩3 ↩4 ↩5 ↩6 ↩7 ↩8 ↩9 ↩10

  2. Pew Research Center, "Social Media and News Fact Sheet", October 19, 2026. Survey of 5,166 US adults, August 24 to 30, 2026. ↩ ↩2 ↩3 ↩4 ↩5 ↩6 ↩7

  3. Pew Research Center, "Where Americans are getting their news in the digital age", The Briefing, October 22, 2026. Survey of US adults, August 24 to 30, 2026; news influencer figure from a 2025 Pew-Knight survey. ↩ ↩2 ↩3

  4. Search Engine Land, July 2025, reporting on Pew Research Center's analysis of the browsing data of 900 US adults from March 2025. ↩

  5. Reuters, "AI assistants make widespread errors about the news, new research shows", October 22, 2025, on research by the European Broadcasting Union and the BBC testing ChatGPT, Copilot, Gemini and Perplexity in 14 languages. ↩ ↩2

  6. CNN, "Nearly 20% of TikTok search results yield videos with misinformation, report says", September 2022, on NewsGuard's review of the top 20 results for 27 news searches. ↩

  7. Pew Research Center, "Americans' Trust in Information From News Organizations Has Risen in the Past Year", November 2, 2026. Survey conducted September 2026. ↩

  8. BrightLocal, "Local Consumer Review Survey 2026", February 11, 2026. Representative panel of 1,002 US adults. ↩ ↩2 ↩3 ↩4

Pass it on

Know someone who needs this?

Send it to one business owner who’s been wrestling with this. The message is already written. It takes five seconds, and it might save them months.

Or share it on social

A caption, ready to paste

What's the Most Reliable Source of Information Now? Google, AI, TikTok, Reddit and More, Checked Where people really get their information in 2026, how far each source can be trusted, and what that means for the way customers decide to hire you. Worth the read 👇 https://jds1marketing.com/most-reliable-source-of-information/

Tip: on LinkedIn, add one sentence of your own take above it. That’s what starts the conversation.

Keep reading